Thursday, June 29, 2017

How to Cure a Cancer: Thoughts on Improving Academic Journals

So, I currently have a paper that has been under review since last December, coming up on 7 months. A friend of mine recently waited something like 16-17 months at the JME. This is ridiculous. It doesn't seem like it would be that difficult to design a system in which this doesn't happen, or happens only very rarely. It's led me to think about all the ways the academic economics publishing system could be improved. Particularly since economists study incentives, you'd think we could design a good system.  All economists know and believe there are obvious problems in the academic publishing system, and yet, somehow, the profession soldiers on like a drunken sailor.  Thus, here are a few proposals, most of which are obvious and probably not new:

1. A recent positive trend is that many journals pay referees for finishing a report within a certain number of days. I approve. However, my paper is currently at such a journal, which has limit of 4-6 weeks (range given to protect the anonymity of the journal). After that, a referee gets nothing. What I wonder, then, is if a referee misses the deadline, they no longer have any incentive to write a report sooner rather than later. I also wonder if this doesn't make them more likely to delay. If the deadline was 30 days, and you wake up on day 31, and realize you've missed a payday, it seems you might be less likely to submit the report on day 31, feeling like a chump. A phase out of the payment over several months would likely be more effective. Here's another idea, why I'm throwing them out: referees should be given an option to have a larger payoff with a short duration of a referee report -- say, two weeks -- while also agreeing to pay if they don't finish a report within two months, with a fee increasing incrementally each month. And would need to provide their credit card information in advance. The fee for backing out could be set to be even worse than submitting a report at each date, to make this incentive compatible.

2. Another problem is that much research is funded by the government, or by universities paid for by tuition dollars, and yet academic research is not a public good. Academic journals make bank. First, academics write papers and submit them to journals, and not only do they do this free of charge, but they actually pay for the right to have the fruits of their free labor published, for the benefit of the journal owners. We must do this, of course, as our academic careers depend on publishing in fancy journals. Our careers are also helped by prestigious editing positions at journals, which we are also happy to do for free or low wages. Referees then, also, typically work for free or at least below-market wages. Next, the journals charge lots of money to the same universities which pay their professors for access to the same research the universities pay professors to produce. It's a great business to be in, if you can get it. The issue is that the most prestigious journals have near monopolies -- the tradeoff is that one Top 5 publication is seen as being worth 4-5 publications in Top Fields (at least for your first one) -- a crazy ratio, but the profession is obsessed with rank and status. The solution here is some form of collective action. For example, the government should tax academic journal profits, and could use the proceeds to help fund education, or it could regulate the fees that journals charge for libraries or the public to access the research. If the Ivy League, or the UC system were to spell out that only research published in open access journals or which obey some other criterion would result in tenure, this could be a start. The problems and solutions here are so obvious I'm hesitant to write it down. A dream of mine is also to devise a journal ranking system which penalizes journals for bad behavior (e.g., for high fees to libraries, or high submission fees), so that departments could change the ranking system which they use to award tenure and promotion decisions, in order to better incentivize journals. 

3. A third problem is that referees, and even journal editors, have limited incentives to try and do a good job, much less a timely job. One thing I propose here is for journals to ask authors for feedback on how the referee and editorial process went.  Clearly, when someone gets a negative referee report, they will give someone a bad ranking, but overall referee scores could be computed controlling for the recommendation of the report. Partly, I think this would be good for purely therapeutic reasons, even if the journals didn't use this for anything. When you're pissed off after getting yet another clueless report, you now have an outlet -- you can kill them in your referee Eval! However, the journals could band together to create a referee ranking. Editors and other referees could also rate referees. There are certainly cases where referees say crazy things, and this is acknowledged by not only the authors, but the editor and other referees. And yet, the said referee pays no penalty at all. On the contrary, they may receive the benefit of not being asked to referee again for some time. If a system were designed to give feedback to departments: "your professor X has a history of providing unprofessional reports", or simply: "here is the rank of your APs in terms of their prowess writing referee reports", this could change incentives for the better. 
4. Another problem is that journals have no incentives to publish comment papers, which tend to reflect poorly on the journal, and which also tend to be poorly cited. Thus, in the ranking system I devised above, I would penalize journals that don't accept comment papers on papers published in its own journal. 







16 comments:

  1. Long ago, when papers were read at society meetings, the editors recruited discussants, whose comments and a response from the author were printed together with the paper. These made for interesting reading. Since the whole thing was public, everybody got credit or blame. Even the editor's choice of discussants was on display, so that anyone in the know could tell whether he (and it would have been a he in those days) was being fair. I don't think some modern version of that would speed things up, but having the reviews public would certainly improve their quality.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is an interesting idea. I support it. We spend so much time writing referee reports, and put so much time and effort responding to referee reports, that what is the point of keeping all this information secret? One issue is that if the referee is known, then the referee might have incentive to recommend acceptance if it is a big, powerful guy or a journal editor. In that case, some anonymity is useful.

      In fact, I also have experimented with making the referee reports I receive public. I think, in one case this worked out well. A later referee recommended accept, and said he found my responses to previous referees helpful and persuasive. In the other case, I'm not so sure. Referees might have looked at it and thought -- many previous referees didn't like it, it must be bad work. Sure, I didn't think the previous referees had raised any serious issues, in fact, I thought most the points raised were either wrong or minor, but others could well come to a different view. Another worry, which I may be in danger of here, is insulting my past referees, even though they are anonymous. So let me also say that I've also received many brilliant referee reports! I also made public a referee report in which I recommended "reject" on a paper topic closely related to one of my papers public and put it on my webpage. I put it up since I stand by my comments, and also because I don't want to be an academic gatekeeper. I won't do this when I recommend accept, however, as that could be self-serving.

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

      Delete
    3. Having Herpes is a Terrible Experience and my Experience will help some hsv patients beware of Herbs from online doc.
      I was positive to the deadly virus called HERPES and i lost hope because i
      was out casted and rejected even by my closet friends.
      i searched on-line to know and enquirer about cure for HERPES and i read
      someone testimony on how he was cured from HSV-2 so i decided to contact
      the same herbalist Call Dr Edidia because i know that nature has the power
      to heal everything.
      i contacted him to know how he can help me and he told me never to worry
      that he will help me with the natural herbs from God!
      after 2 days of contacting him, he told me that the cure has been ready and
      he sent it to me via UPS SPEED POST and it got to me after 3 days!
      i used the medicine as he instructed me (MORNING and EVENING) and i was
      cured!
      its really like a dream but i am so happy!
      thats the reason i decided to also add more comment of Him so that more can
      be saved just like me!
      and if you need his help, you can email him on dredidiaherbalhome@gmail.com
      or whatsapp +2349074505296
      here is the Dr Blog page
      http://dredidiaherbalhome.blogspot.com

      https://herbalcureforhbv.blogspot.com
      facebook page
      https://www.facebook.com/dredidiaherbalhome/

      I,m rosesharon and you can get intouch with me via rosesharon915@gmail.com

      Delete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am Vera Jones, and I am base in USA...My life is back!!! After 1 years of broken marriage, my husband left me with two kids. I felt like my life was about to end i almost committed suicide, I was emotionally down for a very long time. Thanks to a spell caster
    called Dr Jack, which i met online. On one faithful day, as I was browsing through the internet, I came across allot of testimonies about this particular spell caster. Some people testified that he brought their Ex lover back, some testified that he restores womb,how he cured them of HIV/AIDS and other sickness, some testified that he can cast a spell to stop divorce and so on. i also come across one particular testimony, it was about a woman called Sonia, she testified about how he brought back her Ex lover in less than 7
    days, and at the end of her testimony she dropped Dr Jack's e-mail address. After reading all these, I decided to give it a try. I contacted him via email and explained my problem to him. In just 72 hours, my husband came back to me. We resolved our issues, and we are
    even happier than before Dr Jack, He is really a gifted man and i will not stop publishing him because he is a wonderful man... If you have a problem and you are looking for a real and genuine spell caster to solve all your problems for you. Try Dr Jack anytime, he might be the answer to your problems. contact the great Doctor through this mail: Morinjack67@gmail.com you can also follow him on instagram:Jacksolutiontemple and on whatsapp:+2348130935053

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello everyone in this forum, i will keep sharing my own experience with the world what Dr JOHN has done for me, he cure my HIV/AIDS. i was suffering from HIV/aids for more than 3 years until i got the email of this great healer from the Internet and choose to give him a trial to see if he can really help me. to my greatest surprise this man help me with his herbal medicine and now my pains are all gone, i went to the hospital to do some test and the result came out negative. i am free from my HIV/aids sickness and i a very happy now, i will like you to help me thank this great healer Dr JOHN on his email: drjohnhivcurehome@gmail.com You can reach him through his whats-app +2347064365391 truly here is a really healing home of all sickness. CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-
    1. HIV/AIDS
    2. HERPES
    3. CANCER
    4. ALS
    5. Hepatitis
    6 Diabetes
    7 LOVE SPELL
    8 lymphoma
    9 IF YOU NEED YOUR EX LOVER BACK TO LOVE YOU AGAIN.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello everyone in this forum, i will keep sharing my own experience with the world what Dr JOHN has done for me, he cure my HIV/AIDS. i was suffering from HIV/aids for more than 3 years until i got the email of this great healer from the Internet and choose to give him a trial to see if he can really help me. to my greatest surprise this man help me with his herbal medicine and now my pains are all gone, i went to the hospital to do some test and the result came out negative. i am free from my HIV/aids sickness and i a very happy now, i will like you to help me thank this great healer Dr JOHN on his email: drjohnhivcurehome@gmail.com You can reach him through his whats-app +2347064365391 truly here is a really healing home of all sickness. CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-
    1. HIV/AIDS
    2. HERPES
    3. CANCER
    4. ALS
    5. Hepatitis
    6 Diabetes
    7 LOVE SPELL
    8 lymphoma
    9 IF YOU NEED YOUR EX LOVER BACK TO LOVE YOU AGAIN.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello everyone in this forum, i will keep sharing my own experience with the world what Dr JOHN has done for me, he cure my HIV/AIDS. i was suffering from HIV/aids for more than 3 years until i got the email of this great healer from the Internet and choose to give him a trial to see if he can really help me. to my greatest surprise this man help me with his herbal medicine and now my pains are all gone, i went to the hospital to do some test and the result came out negative. i am free from my HIV/aids sickness and i a very happy now, i will like you to help me thank this great healer Dr JOHN on his email: drjohnhivcurehome@gmail.com You can reach him through his whats-app +2347064365391 truly here is a really healing home of all sickness. CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-
    1. HIV/AIDS
    2. HERPES
    3. CANCER
    4. ALS
    5. Hepatitis
    6 Diabetes
    7 LOVE SPELL
    8 lymphoma
    9 IF YOU NEED YOUR EX LOVER BACK TO LOVE YOU AGAIN.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hello everyone in this forum, i will keep sharing my own experience with the world what Dr JOHN has done for me, he cure my HIV/AIDS. i was suffering from HIV/aids for more than 3 years until i got the email of this great healer from the Internet and choose to give him a trial to see if he can really help me. to my greatest surprise this man help me with his herbal medicine and now my pains are all gone, i went to the hospital to do some test and the result came out negative. i am free from my HIV/aids sickness and i a very happy now, i will like you to help me thank this great healer Dr JOHN on his email: drjohnhivcurehome@gmail.com You can reach him through his whats-app +2347064365391 truly here is a really healing home of all sickness. CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-
    1. HIV/AIDS
    2. HERPES
    3. CANCER
    4. ALS
    5. Hepatitis
    6 Diabetes
    7 LOVE SPELL
    8 lymphoma
    9 IF YOU NEED YOUR EX LOVER BACK TO LOVE YOU AGAIN.

    ReplyDelete
  10. It is no longer news that the Acquired immune deficiency syndrome /Human Immuno Virus (HIV/AIDS) is increasing by the day. The fear is that many people living with the sickness are scared of saying it because of the stigma that comes along with it. I am bold enough among many others to state that there is now a potent cure to this sickness but many are unaware of it. I discovered that I was infected with the virus 8yrs ago, after a medical check-up. My doctor told me and I was shocked, confused and felt like my world has crumbled. I was dying slowly due the announcement of my medical practitioner but he assured me that I could lead a normal life if I took my medications (as there was no medically known cure to HIV). I went from churches to churches but soon found that my case needed urgent attention as I was growing lean due to fear of dying anytime soon. In a bid to looking for a lasting solution to my predicament, I sought for solutions from the DR JOHN world. I went online and searched for every powerful trade-medical practitioner that I could severe, cos I heard that the DR JOHN had a cure to the HIV syndrome. It was after a little time surfing the web that I came across one DR JOHN (A powerful MAN DR JOHN , who offered to help me at a monetary fee. I had to comply as this was my final bus-stop to receiving a perfect healing. My last resolve was to take my life by myself, should this plan fail. Alas! it worked out well. He gave my some steps to follow and I meticulously carried out all his instructions. Last month, 13 SEPTEMBER, 2013, to be precise, I went back to the hospital to conduct another test and to my amazement, the results showed that " I am NEGATIVE". You can free yourself of this HIV virus by consulting this great DR JOHN via this e-mail: drjohnhivcurehome@gmail.com Or you can reach him through his whats-app +2347064365391 he will help you am %100 sure on that

    ReplyDelete

  11. My mum had small cell terminal lung cancer. She lost her hair while going through chemo and it was devastated. She has recently finished her radiotherapy and she was losing her hair again :( mum wanted me to shave it off again as it's coming out in clumps.i know she was very upset and have told her to be confident it'll grow back but she's so upset, life became hell for me, because i just cant imagine my mum this way. i actually posted this online, and somebody replied me, that he knows once who can cure my mum, without spending much money and without taking anytime anymore, and there wont be any hair loss anymore. I said okay and i want to give it a try, the person that helped him (the person that i was referred to) is Dr Covenant, his email is covenantsolutiontemple@gmail.com, he gave me his email address and i contacted him and told him everything, he (Dr Covenant) said i should not worry everything'll be okay in space of 8 days, i actually gave him a try.
    It was not up to the 3rd day, i started noticing changes in my mum. Now my mum is healthy back and the cancer is gone. Am so grateful about this. I actually thought that my mum was going to die, but now she is still alive. Friends, if you have any problem such as cancer, or other illness like HIV/AIDS, GONORRHEA, or any other illness at all, and he is also specialized in getting ex back contact Dr Covenant on his email covenantsolutiontemple@gmail.com or add him on watsapp on +2349057353987 or call him directly on +2348146671563. you can also go through his website if interested http://covenantspelltemple.blogspot.com.
    MY BEST FRIEND IS STILL ALIVE, AM GRATEFUL COVENANT.

    ReplyDelete
  12. It’s obvious some patient with HERPES/HIV/CANCER are been enslaved to the antiviral and other supplementary Orthodox medicine just to help suppress the virus and not a cure. I have been with the virus since 2012 until I was introduce by a blogger who also narrated her story online on how she was cured of Genital Herpes after using Dr Jones herbal Medicine. This is a year and 2 weeks since I was delivered from Herpes. All thanks to God for using this Great herbalist to heal me. I have promise to keep telling good about Dr jones. Please fill free to share Your problems with him and don’t forget to tell him I did refer you to Him. Thanks. Write him on mail bantespelltemple@gmail.com or WhatsApp him on +2347059073543. He deals with Alzheimer virus, Copd, Cancer HIV Herpes Genital warts ALS BV UTI Virginal infection Genital Wart HPV Hepatitis A/B Good luck HSV Pregnancy Ex back

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hello,

    Dr Ogudugu, a real and genuine spell caster/Spiritual healer with years of experience in spell casting and an expert in all spells, specialize exclusively in LOVE SPELL/GET REUNITE WITH EX LOVER, MONEY SPELL, POWERFUL MAGIC RING, ANY COURT CASES, FRUIT OF THE WOMB, HIV CURE, CURE FOR CANCER, SAVE CHILD BIRTH. They are all %110 Guaranteed QUICK Results, it most work. If you have any problem and you need a real and genuine spell caster to solve your problems, contact now through his personal Email Address with problem case...Note-you can also Text/Call on
    WhatsApp.

    Contact
    Email: greatogudugu@gmail.com
    WhatsApp No: +27663492930

    ReplyDelete